- 2635 Sandy Plains Road, Marietta
- Latest health score: 90
This place is a hole in the wall with a New York accent. Literally, nearly all the workers and the people who buy their slices here have what people where I grew up in Mobile, Alabama, would snootily call “a Yankified accent.”
Our first foray to this small pizza place came after a shopping trip at Town Center Mall, where the Young Adult Son and I marveled at the blown-out lights, vacant shops and overall decrepitude of our closest mall. Last year, the mall closed briefly after the mall owner failed to pay the power bill. The property is currently being managed by JLL, according to the mall website. The future seems more than a little bleak judging from the evidence.





But I digress. After wandering the mall, we were hungry and started driving somewhat aimlessly in the general direction of East Cobb. I was on the verge of hangry. Luckily, the Young Adult Son was able to find a pizza place off of Sandy Plains: LaBella’s. Because of our bad timing, driving during the 5 p.m. hour, it took a friggin’ eternity to make it from the left turn from Piedmont to Sandy Plains. I would recommend avoiding that area, or driving at all, particularly in that intersection.
Though the address of LaBella’s says it’s on Sandy Plains, you have to turn left onto Kinjack Road to get there. The location is roughly across Sandy Plains from where that old Bruno’s and decrepit shopping center used to be. It has since been torn down and redeveloped into housing.
Labella’s is in a small, old and unimpressive little shopping center. The Labella’s mural on one of the inside walls — showing a pizza going into a brick over — gives it a small touch of class the rest of the establishment doesn’t possess. It’s like all the class of the place was used up in the creation of the mural, leaving the rest of the place feeling more like a Greyhound station in a medium-sized Southern town.
The place feels like it hasn’t changed since possibly the Carter administration. It could fit right in with the “Barney Miller” extended universe, somehow. Don’t expect digital screens or even TV screens here. You’ll be giving your order to a human with a New York accent, who will write it down on a piece of paper, old-school style. I’m not sure what they do with the paper, because then someone will need to be told what you ordered, and then you’ll be asked a couple of times whether you want to eat here or take your food to go.
The establishment is quite cluttered, pizza boxes in towers, various other items. It’s very homey if you have the sort of home where you also don’t have room for all your stuff and have to stack things in various places. It’s fine.
The Young Adult Son warned the pies were somewhat expensive, so we opted to try other items on the menu. I chose a calzone with pepperoni. The Young Adult Son decided on a Italian sandwich.
Because this restaurant is New York style, the service is very business-like. Don’t expect chit-chat or anyone asking how you’re doing here.
While we waited, we sat at a table. Basically the seating area is eight tables, four tables on each side that have been pushed together into one long table. Thus, you are forced to be among people and perhaps listen to their conversations. An older couple came in after us, and the dude was a bit upset they weren’t going to make a slice exactly the way he wanted, but he ended up buying some other kind of slice. The couple then sat at the other end of our table talking about the bone spurs of someone they knew and generic medicines not being as good. The Young Adult Son said he felt like he was in New York, even though it’s a state he has never really visited, so he doesn’t even know what it’s like there.
At some point during our stay there, a regular came in and started chatting with the workers about donating plasma. If humanity makes you squirm, you can always order ahead and get your pizza to go.
Don’t expect your food fast. It’s not that kind of place, not for the sandwiches and calzones at least. But what we got was good. The Young Adult Son devoured his sandwich and said it was delicious.
The calzone was also very tasty, piping hot and fresh with two kinds of cheese and marinara dipping sauce, rather than sauce on the inside like some other places. I ate a bit of it there since I was very hungry and took the rest to go to enjoy later. Calzone is a great value for me since it took me more than one sitting to finish it. The marinara tastes homemade and a little on the sweet side for my liking.
Because it is a pizza place, I ended up returning by myself the very next week to get pizza. For sciene.
When I asked the older gentleman about the possibility of buying a small pizza, he shook his head “no” and told me to buy a slice. So that’s what I did, but instead of taking my pizza and walking down the sidewalk like John Travolta’s character in “Saturday Night Fever,” (he gets his pizza at @1:54 in the video below), I had to just drive home because we are in the suburbs. 😦
The pizza is OK, (the calzone is much better, to me) but I would not recommend ordering mushrooms on your pizza since the topping seems like it came straight from the can, which is a sin that is borderline unforgiveable. Slice some fresh mushrooms, FFS!
The rest of the pizza was pretty decent, though. The proper cheese to sauce combo was maintained, the crust was the proper thickness and yummy, and they didn’t skimp on the pepperonis. The garlic knots rocked, though I like my garlic knots to be more imbued with a garlic oil, though there’s the marinara sauce for dipping.
The Young Adult Son lauds the knots, which he says tastes more authentic than most. Despite the lack of oil, he has a point!




























